Exodus of Healthcare Professionals as NHI Introduction Nears
The prospect of an exodus of doctors and other key healthcare personnel from South Africa ahead of the planned introduction of the National Health Insurance (NHI) scheme has prompted concern among healthcare stakeholders.
In addition to the loss of skilled healthcare professionals, there is also a growing concern that the country could lose valuable training skills as professionals look to leave.
Thirteen years on from its inception, the NHI continues to suffer from the same criticisms. A May 2021 research paper [PDF} found that South Africa’s per capita spending on public healthcare was higher than even wealthier developing countries, yet it ranked near the bottom for measures of healthcare outcomes.
An informal poll on the QuickNews website in March showed that 81% of respondents had at least considered emigrating due to the planned introduction of NHI.
Professional associations are also warning of an exodus with the start of NHI. The South African Medical Association (SAMA) has said that its members cannot support the NHI in its current form.
This stems from a deep-rooted lack of confidence in the capacity of government and its financial ability to ensure the service is successful, the association said. Other concerns that members have raised include only providing emergency treatment to refugees and illegal immigrants, as well as their children.
SAMA conducted a survey which showed that up to 38% of its members plan to emigrate from South Africa due to the planned introduction of the NHI.
6% of members said that they plan to emigrate for other reasons, while 17% of doctors said that they were unsure about leaving the country. Many doctors have said that the aim should rather be to get the public sector to a state where it can appeal to private sector patients.
They added that there should be engagement with private doctors to provide additional services funded by the state. The group also called for a proper pilot of the proposed systems and payment mechanisms.
The Department of Health noted these concerns in a parliamentary briefing this week, noting that skilled personnel will be needed for the NHI to work. It added that this was not limited to healthcare professionals, but that general skilled human resources will be central to the health system going forward.
It added that the complex interactions between training, registration compliance and employment can all be greatly improved.
“This is a big ship that will need to be turned, but the framework is in place,” said acting director-general of health Dr Nicholas Crisp. “We have heard the threats that there will be an exodus of personnel if the NHI is implemented and a brain drain.”
The department is actively responding to this, he said, with a framework in place to ensure the country retains the necessary skills. A ‘Human Resources for Health strategy’ before was already under development before the start of the COVID pandemic, he added.
This framework sets out a multi-work implementation plan, but it requires money and investment in the health workforce to ensure the country is ready for universal health coverage, Dr Crisp said.
“Every health professional has a place in the National Health Insurance – whether you choose to work in the public portion of the delivery system or the private portion of that delivery system.
“We do not think there needs to be a threat on anybody, or their viability, or their role to be played.”
Source: BusinessTech
