On Sunday evening, another fire broke out at Steve Biko Academic Hospital – the second in two weeks. The fire damaged linen and prompted an evacuation but fortunately, there were no injuries resulting from the incident, Times Live reported.
Gauteng health department spokesperson Kwara Kekana said the cause of the latest fire was due to till-burning cigarette butts discarded by patients which “touched the ward linen room lights, burning the steel shelves and linen.”
Kekana said the damage was limited to a few items of linin. The fire started at around 6.15pm in a linen closet in a medical ward.
“The fire was quickly extinguished by staff. Patients were temporarily evacuated as a safety precaution because of smoke. By 8.15pm, patients were returned to the ward after the City of Tshwane declared the site safe,” Kekana said.
The previous fire at the hospital broke out at around 1:20am in a temporary storage area for COVID medical waste and as an in-transit corpse area. That fire affected temporary structures outside the hospital casualty area, and forced the evacuation of 18 patients.
This is the latest in a string of fires in Gauteng hospitals, such as the devastating fire at Charlotte Maxeke hospital – something which has caused concern for Gauteng Health MEC Nomathemba Mokgethi.
Speaking about the previous fire, she said that, “It looks like every year in the Department of Health we have to deal with fires. I will be getting a report the afternoon from the law enforcement agency, especially on the Charlotte issue.”
The problem of hospital fires is not confined to Gauteng: exactly a week earlier, a blaze broke out at Chatsmed Hospital in Durban.
The whistle-blowing paediatrician Dr Tim de Maayer who spoke out about appalling conditions at Rahima Moosa Mother and Child Hospital (RMMCH) was suspended yesterday, apparently in a retaliatory move.
In the widely-read open letter appearing on the Daily Maverick, he spoke of the preventable tragedy of babies dying due to lack of resources. This came shortly after a viral video showed pregnant mothers sleeping on the floor.
Presciently, the Daily Maverick, which broke the story, stated that there were two options: act to change the situation for the better, or “shoot the messenger”. As the newspaper wryly noted as it broke the news on Friday, 10 June, the option of shooting the messenger has been taken.
Although there appeared to be an initial positive response, Dr Maayer gave notice on Thursday evening that he was not able to come into work on Friday as he was being placed on suspension. RMMCH doctors then contacted the Daily Maverick.
His suspension leaves the hospital without its only paediatric gastroenterologist, according to an anxious doctor who got in touch with the Daily Maverick late Thursday night. The news has spread like wildfire across social media, with other doctors quick to come to Dr de Maayer’s defence.
A petition on Change.org to reinstate the paediatrician is being circulated by ordinary citizens and clinicians including Professor Shabir Madhi, who has been vocal in his support of Dr de Maayer.
The Progressive Health Forum (PHF) called for the suspension of Dr de Maayer to be overturned.
“Dr de Maayer has been suspended on the grounds that he has a voice, a conscience and a professional ethic and being a committed public health clinician. This pattern of victimisation has been repeatedly applied to clinicians who dare call out inadequacies of the administration and negative impact on clinicians and on the lives of patients,” the PHF said in a statement.
Doctors have come out in support of criticism of the conditions at Rahima Moosa Mother and Child Hospital (RMMCH) in Johannesburg. The dire situation at the hospital, which has reportedly resulted in numerous patient deaths, has been highlighted on a number of occasions.
A year ago, Daily Maverick visited RMMCH after concerns being voiced by doctors and patients, and found a number of problems there. This year, a viral video clip showed pregnant women sleeping on the floor at the Gauteng hospital, and Daily Maverick returned to found the situation had worsened, yet the hospital’s CEO Dr Nozuko Mkabayi emphatically denied anything was amiss.
Dr Mkabayi said that although the hospital experiences periodic drug stockouts and equipment shortages, “Patients’ lives are not in danger and there is enough essential equipment. The hospital equipment committee is functional in ensuring adequate equipment needs for patient care.”
Then paediatrician Dr Tim de Maayer wrote an open letter to the Department of Health which sent further shockwaves through the media.
He said that his patients were dying due to a simple lack of basic resources. Drugs were in short supply; staff were massively overloaded; the hospital’s generators were ill-equipped to handle load shedding; and even water supply was threatened, causing hospital-acquired infections to spread “like wildfire”. These issues, Dr Maayer noted, had been raised with management before.
Gift of the Givers had stepped in and sunk a borehole to assist with the water supply situation – although a charity having to come to the rescue of a public hospital is an embarrassment.
Department of Health spokesperson Kwara Kekana acknowledged that the infrastructure was lacking:
“The hospital has over the past decade seen an increase in patient load with no increase in infrastructure development,” she said. “It has steadily increased intake from 10 000 deliveries to 16 000 deliveries per year, which is the second highest in the country.”
“To add more capacity, the hospital has repurposed 22 beds to accommodate more antenatal patients in the last two years making a total of 56 antenatal beds, which is still insufficient.”
RMMCH had requested exemption from the load shedding schedule, she noted.
In an interview with eNCA, Professor Haroon Saloojee, head of community paediatrics at Wits Universiy, said that he “wholeheartedly” agreed with Dr Mayeer, saying that, “what I think he is describing is the ‘complete storm'” and it “contributes to a reduction in quality care.
“[…]it’s the issue of inadequate staff, just not enough doctors but particularly nurses for the patient load – and certainly for the situation at Rahima Moosa has been far worsened that Charlotte Maxeke has been closed for so long and they’ve had to take the load. So a very busy hospital with a greatly increased number of deliveries as the load has become more. Added to that a problem with getting adequate equipment, he makes that point. And to add to that we’ve had both the crises with water availability and to top that all the regular loadshedding which means the generators weren’t coping.
“So you end up with a major storm and shouldn’t surprise then that children’s lives get affected.”
Regarding procurement issues such as running out of bread he remarked, “I’m sure there’s a lot of bureaucracy, but a lot of it is the simple management of the day-to-day running of a hospital, including how it places accounts, and the truth is that many hospitals are forfeiting at that.”
Since his letter went out, Dr Maayer has said there has been some reaction from the government, with President Ramaphosa reportedly wanting to see a response from RMMCH’s CEO. Deputy Health Minister, Sibongiseni Dhlomo has said that the letter is worrying and will be looked into.
10 March 2022: Shabir Madhi addresses the crowd outside Baragwanath hospital. Credit: Nation Nyoka
Despite falling struggling staff and falling patient care at Baragwanath Hospital, the contracts of 800 support staff will not be renewed, writes Nation Nyoka for New Frame.
Budget cuts at the Gauteng Department of Health mean that it will not renew the contracts of more than 800 COVID support staff at Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital, south of Johannesburg, on 31 March.
A picket was held outside the hospital on Thursday 10 March after it emerged that suppliers hadn’t been paid for services such as bread delivery and biohazardous waste removal.
Chief executive Nkele Lesia said on 11 March that the picket was less about the COVID staff and more about staff shortages. But she offered no plan to address the inadequate number of hospital personnel. Lesia said the COVID staff knew their contracts were not going to be renewed.
“Those 800 posts may have been created for COVID-19, but it provides us an opportunity to redress this imbalance that exists with this hospital having been chronically understaffed,” said Shabir Madhi, a vaccinology professor and the dean of health sciences at the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits). “We can’t just remove the staff – we need to incorporate them into the system so that we can have this hospital better staffed to ensure better quality of patient care.”
He said the issue goes beyond staff shortages. “If we remove them, we will find that the permanent staff come under greater pressure and burn out. They are going to resign, creating a greater disaster. Poor planning on the part of the government is not an excuse to punish patients and healthcare workers.”
Gauteng member of the executive council for health Nomathemba Mokgethi said the department is unable to absorb the temporary staff because of budget constraints. But she extended her appreciation for their help and support during the waves of COVID.
A chronic situation
Madhi said neglect and the inadequate management and training of healthcare workers over the past two years will materialise as a heavier burden from chronic diseases, which have been on the back-burner as the healthcare industry prioritised COVID.
“For the next two to three years, we need to expect high levels of people ending up in hospital dying not because of COVID. With COVID, there has unquestionably been a disruption in the care of patients with other conditions because people haven’t been able to access facilities. People have been delayed in the diagnosis, and for some time they probably delayed with the treatment,” he said.
Mokgethi and her team did not offer a plan to handle diseases that have been neglected either.
Madhi said training has been hampered and Baragwanath – one of the biggest academic teaching hospitals on the Wits circuit – needs to function properly for students to learn comprehensively. “It is going to impact patient care in the years to come, so the disaster we sit upon today is just the beginning of a further rot of the system if we don’t reverse it immediately.”
Mmampapatla Ramokgopa, chairperson of the hospital’s medical advisory committee, said resilient and hard-working staff who have gone the extra mile are what has kept Baragwanath going.
“We have doctors and nurses pushing patients because there are no porters. The same with cleaning. You find nurses and doctors scrubbing the floors because there are not enough cleaners. Sometimes patients delay to get into theatres because the cleaners are not there. They dig into their pockets and make contributions to buy either bread or flour to make bread,” said Ramokgopa.
Patient care at risk
The department denied that Gauteng hospitals have run out of food, saying other types of food are being served at Baragwanath. It did admit that the hospital, along with other facilities, experienced “a short supply of bread in the recent past” and that the issue had been resolved.
Madhi said the hospital and surrounding area were compromised when the department failed to pay the service provider who removes biohazardous waste. The department said on 11 March that it had paid the relevant service providers to collect the waste and supply bread.
“The fact that we are in a province where patients are not provided something as basic as bread for two weeks speaks volumes about the incompetence and uncaringness of those responsible for the management of this facility … at the level of the province,” said Madhi.
Ramokgopa said the committee has raised these matters over time. People who have worked at the hospital for years have a collective memory of its legacy and they are eager to engage and find solutions.
National Union of Public Service and Allied Workers branch secretary Monwabisi Somi said employees are providing much-needed staff for an institution that is under strain, and the COVID workers need to be absorbed. “We’ve also got the issue of telephone lines that have not been working for some time in some units, which compromises communication. This is to the detriment of patient care,” he said.
Lerato Madyo, the provincial department’s acting chief financial officer, said its finances are healthy but it is dealing with a backlog of unprocessed invoices from previous years. The department owed service providers R4.2 billion at the end of January.
Madhi said what is happening in state healthcare facilities is compromising the future care of people in South Africa. “It is undermining our ability to provide adequate training to healthcare workers.”
Gauteng Premier David Makhura has stated that the province is not vaccinating enough people, which he acknowledged jeopardises its ambitious plans of having 70% of the population vaccinated by year end.
In a media briefing on Monday regarding the province’s vaccination rollout, he revealed that of Sunday, 5.3 million vaccines have been administered. More than 2.6 million people in Gauteng have been fully vaccinated. Gauteng’s infection rate has stabilised, with the number of active cases having fallen to approximately 1000.
The Premier said that as things currently stand, there are still 4.4 million people in Gauteng that have to be vaccinated by the end of December. Makhura said that while they are still focussed on the target, it is becoming difficult to achieve, given the low numbers of people coming in for vaccinations.
“We are not retreating on our target of 70%, but the idea that we will meet 70% by mid-December is becoming a target that is elusive. The vaccination rate per day in Gauteng, on average during the week we are just between 52 and 58 000. We have fallen below the mid 60 000 daily vaccination rate. In September, we were doing extremely well. We were getting around 65-75 000.”
Based on last week’s total of 313 790 vaccinations, with 11 weeks in the year that would mean only about 3.5 million vaccinations administered – let alone persons fully vaccinated with a second dose. Concerns had been voiced at the end of September about flagging vaccination rates in South Africa as a whole.
Makhura also highlighted the low turnout of people in the province’s townships.
“Our townships are lagging behind. The substantial vaccinations are happening in more suburban areas, and the townships are lagging behind. Those townships in the south, Orange Farm and Palestine, we have the lowest number of vaccinations in the south of Johannesburg, that’s where we have 11% vaccination in terms of just single doses,” he said.
Professor Bruce Mellado, of the Gauteng Provincial Command Council, said that, there was still a need to be cautious, especially with big events on the horizon, such as the municipal elections, saying:
“While the situation in the Gauteng Province remains stable and low risk, the risk of a fourth wave is very, very high. In fact, we predict that the fourth wave will hit sometime between November and January as we expect a number of super-spreader events to follow in a row. That’s something we have to have in mind.”
“We should not be confused or misled by the fact that we are currently in a situation of low risk, but that can change quite rapidly,” Prof Mellado cautioned.
Gauteng Health MEC Nomathemba Mokgethi acknowledged that many ambulance pickups were being delayed in the province, but placed the blame for this on the referral system.
Starting in 2019, the Gauteng government has taken over most municipal emergency services. However, due to the pressure placed by COVID, City of Tshwane and City of Ekurhuleni municipalities will receive temporary licences to continue operating ambulance services. “So, combined they will be able to respond to our communities on time,” said MEC Nomathemba Mokgethi.
Tomorrow we will be launching over 300 new vehicles that will add to the EMS fleet. This will be different categories of vehicles : Ambulances, rescue vehicles, planned patient vehicles, busses, and primary response vehicles.#GrowingGautengTogetherpic.twitter.com/Coa58MCRAV
The province’s ambulances and crews are under severe strain as they cope with a lack of resources, the COVID pandemic, and most recently, violent protests.
The Gauteng Emergency Services has been augmenting its fleet with new vehicles, including a pair of Mfezi armoured ambulances for use in dangerous situations, such as riots, where normal soft-skinned ambulances cannot venture.
For example, these armoured vehicles were deployed during New Year’s Eve at Hillbrow, during which time old furniture is often thrown onto the street as a way to ‘start afresh’ for the New Year. This tradition started in the 1990s. Though there may not be as many defenestrated refrigerators in recent years, numerous injuries from the tradition have required the police to clamp down.
The City of Tshwane, which continues to operate under its own ambulance licence, also acquired an armoured ambulance in 2019.
Jack Bloom of the DA said that the Gauteng Health Department has botched its takeover of all ambulance services in the province. Of the original 90 ambulances in Johannesburg before the transition were available, only 40 were now available, according to Bloom.
Meanwhile, in KwaZulu-Natal, more than 30 private ambulance operators have taken their vehicles off the roads to protect them from the ongoing violence.
While COVID infection rates in Gauteng remain high, Western Cape is now firmly in a third wave, with an average of 1969 new cases a day. The healthcare system there has been monitoring the situation and preparing for the expected surge in cases.
“We are in a steep third wave, driven by the Delta variant and urge everyone to adhere strictly to protective behaviours, as a key drive to contain it. We anticipate that the third wave could be as high as the second wave. We await revised modelling from the SACMC to re-calibrate our response,” said head of health Dr Keith Cloete. Data on cases, healthcare capacity and details of the Western Cape’s responses were made available on the SA Coronavirus Portal.
In the Western Cape, the reproductive number has been over one for the past two months and is currently sitting at approximately 1.2, meaning an acceleration of new cases. The test positivity rate is at about 32%.
The public and private sector are using around two-thirds of the oxygen production capacity of Afrox’s plant. The level 4 restrictions with their accompanying alcohol ban saw a significant drop in week-on-week trauma presentations (~25%) and weekend trauma burden (~33% drop). This comes even with the context typical end of month increase as well as expected remaining alcohol stock, demonstrating the ban’s effectiveness.
The modelling referred to by Dr Cloete currently shows a high of ~500 daily admissions by 17 July, however an updated model is awaited. Public sector COVID bed capacity is being increased by converting beds and opening field hospitals, with a planned capacity of 2300 beds.
About 48.5% and 10.4% of the Western Cape population aged 60+ and 50-59 respectively have been vaccinated so far. Meanwhile, in a media briefing on Friday, Acting Health Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi-Ngubane announced that COVID vaccine registration for South Africans between the ages of 35-49 will open on July 15, with vaccinations for this age group planned to commence on August 1.
As COVID cases continue to rise virtually unabated by the move to Level 2 lockdown, there are reportedly discussions at the National Coronavirus Command Council to tighten the lockdown restrictions.
The Gauteng government wants the province to have tighter lockdown restrictions, as it is host to about half of daily new infections of COVID in the country. Despite the high infection rate in the province, many in Gauteng are against tougher restrictions, such as the Gauteng Education Department and South African Council of Churches. Acting Health Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi-Ngubane says that she will speak to the National Coronavirus Command Council about the issue.
The province’s premier David Makhura said the province is asking for increased measures. “Level 2 as we know it currently is not having a sufficient impact,” he said. “People are going on as if we are really not in the middle of a raging pandemic.”
With Charlotte Maxeke Academic Hospital being indefinitely closed, the pressure is mounting on both public and private facilities which running out of ICU beds.
“So, we talk to the private hospitals almost on a daily basis, and they do indicate to us that they are running almost at about 80% of their capacity for ICU. In the public hospitals, we are also running at about 70%,” said Thabo Masebe, communications head of the Gauteng government.
He confirmed that the province was looking for tougher restrictions to curb new infections.
“That’s what the premier had said. He will be raising that with national government to see what added restrictions could be made to help slow down the rate of infections in the province,” Masebe said.
