Hopes Dashed for Ciclesonide as COVID Treatment
Despite high hopes, the first placebo controlled trial of inhaled steroids for COVID suggests that ciclesonide, an inhaled and nasal steroid drug commonly used for asthma and rhinitis, does not help young healthy people with COVID and respiratory symptoms improve earlier.
The study, published in the BMJ, was motivated by research showing that ciclesonide, which is safe, inexpensive and widely available, could decrease viral replication of SARS-Cov2 in mouse models of COVID. A randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of inhaled ciclesonide was designed to evaluate the resolution of symptoms in adults with COVID presenting with respiratory symptoms.
“Based on my experience treating asthma, I thought it made sense to see if it would decrease the lung inflammation in patients with COVID early in the disease, as lung disease has an important impact for patients and is a major effect of the virus,” explained Dr Nicole Ezer, the first and lead author of the study, who is a lung specialist and a researcher in the Translational Research in Respiratory Diseases Program at the RI-MUHC. “In addition, we felt it was important to study a drug for COVID that has a very good safety profile and could be used in high, middle and low-income countries safely to reduce respiratory symptoms. Access to affordable medications is very important to decrease disparities in health outcomes across the world.”
The importance of placebo control
From Sept. 15, 2020 to June 8, 2021, the study recruited 215 symptomatic adults and randomly assigned them to either inhaled and intranasal ciclesonide or inhaled and intranasal placebo for 14 days. Participants were asked to complete a survey online on the day of enrollment and on six other occasions until day 14, with a follow-up survey at day 29.
Based on the assumption that treatment would be most effective if given early in the disease process, participants were recruited within five days of a positive PCR test result for SARS-CoV-2 and symptom onset and received the treatment at home by commercial courier. No vaccinated participants were included in the trial.
No significant difference was seen between the intervention and control group. After seven days of treatment, 40% taking ciclesonide had no more fever and respiratory symptoms, vs 35% taking placebo. At day 14, these figures amounted to 66% in the ciclesonide group compared with 58% in the placebo group.
Those results are disappointing, especially since two recent open label studies had raised hopes in the scientific community that inhaled steroids could alleviate respiratory symptoms associated with COVID, and one study demonstrated efficacy of dexamethasone in admitted patients with COVID.
“The previously published studies had a major limitation: they were open label with no placebo. Other studies have shown that inhalers have a strong placebo effect,” explained the study’s senior author, Dr Emily McDonald, associate professor of medicine at McGill University. “Here’s a strong reminder that any study of a medication, in particular of inhalers, needs to be controlled with a placebo before we rush to recommend them.”
In spite of the study’s outcome, researchers still believe there is potential for the treatment of COVID with inhaled steroids.
“It’s still possible that inhaled steroids might be beneficial for older at-risk populations,” said Dr Ezer, who is also an assistant professor of medicine at McGill University. “We need more research focused on older adults and people who are high-risk, but those studies must have a placebo arm to make sure they aren’t coming to a false conclusion of benefit.”
Source: McGill University
