Tag: 3/6/24

Supreme Court of Appeal Dismisses Council for Medical Schemes’ Reconsideration Application with Costs

Photo by Bill Oxford on Unsplash

In a significant development for the South African healthcare sector, the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA), has dismissed the Council for Medical Schemes (CMS) and the Registrar for Medical Schemes’ reconsideration application against the Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF) with costs. 

At the signing of the National Health Insurance (NHI) Bill into law, the President asserted that medical schemes were elitist and excluded the majority of the population. However, it is important to note that for many years, medical schemes have actively sought exemptions to provide low-cost benefit options (LCBOs) that would enable more citizens to access medical aid coverage. Despite these efforts, medical schemes face significant regulatory hurdles that prevent them from offering these more inclusive options.

The court’s decision follows the raising of significant concerns by BHF in a letter to the CMS and the registrar, which highlighted key conflicts related to hostility towards medical schemes; unnecessary litigation; delays in developing legal frameworks for low-cost benefit options (LCBOs); ineffective appeal processes; the legality of CMS’s regulatory actions; the influence of the National Health Insurance (NHI) Bill on CMS policies; and the lack of review of Prescribed Minimum Benefits (PMBs) for 24 years. 

Mr Charlton Murove, Head of Research at BHF, said that while the organisation respects the court’s decision, it is unfortunate that a personal cost order against the registrar was not awarded, and that the regulator continues to delay the matter. 

“These delays divert valuable resources, and hinder progress on an issue that is critical to both the South African healthcare industry, and the health of citizens in need of essential services,” added Murove. 

The CMS has since filed the Rule 30A affidavit and the supplementary record. The BHF legal team is currently studying these documents for purposes of moving forward with the main review application, where its members will be updated. 

To this end, BHF remains committed to ensuring a fair and effective regulatory environment for the South African healthcare sector.

“We, as the BHF, will continue to advocate for the interests of our members and the millions of beneficiaries they serve, striving to create a healthcare system that is equitable, transparent, and capable of meeting the needs of all South Africans. 

“This court case is crucial in the context of the National Health Insurance (NHI) as it highlights the necessity of reducing the burden on the state while it prepares for the implementation of NHI, ensuring access to quality healthcare for everyone is essential,” concluded Murove.

Poor Sleep, Social Media Use and Adolescents’ Developing Brains

Photo by Steinar Engeland on Unsplash

A new study to be presented at the SLEEP 2024 annual meeting found a distinct relationship between sleep duration, social media usage, and brain activation across brain regions that are key for executive control and reward processing.

Results show a correlation between shorter sleep duration and greater social media usage in teens. The analysis points to involvement of areas within the frontolimbic brain regions, such as the inferior and middle frontal gyri, in these relationships. The inferior frontal gyrus, key in inhibitory control, may play a crucial role in how adolescents regulate their engagement with rewarding stimuli such as social media. The middle frontal gyrus, involved in executive functions and critical in assessing and responding to rewards, is essential in managing decisions related to the balancing of immediate rewards from social media with other priorities like sleep. These results suggest a nuanced interaction between specific brain regions during adolescence and their influence on behaviour and sleep in the context of digital media usage.

“As these young brains undergo significant changes, our findings suggest that poor sleep and high social media engagement could potentially alter neural reward sensitivity,” said Orsolya Kiss, who has a doctorate in cognitive psychology and is a research scientist at SRI International. “This intricate interplay shows that both digital engagement and sleep quality significantly influence brain activity, with clear implications for adolescent brain development.”

This study involved data from 6516 adolescents, aged 10–14 years, from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development Study. Participants answered questionnaires about sleep duration and recreational social media use. Brain activities were analysed from functional MRI scans during the monetary incentive delay task, targeting regions associated with reward processing. The study used three different sets of models and switched predictors and outcomes each time. Results were adjusted for age, COVID-19 pandemic timing, and socio-demographic characteristics.

Kiss noted that these results provide new insights into how two significant aspects of modern adolescent life, social media usage and sleep duration, interact and impact brain development.

“Understanding the specific brain regions involved in these interactions helps us identify potential risks and benefits associated with digital engagement and sleep habits,” Kiss said. “This knowledge is especially important as it could guide the development of more precise, evidence-based interventions aimed at promoting healthier habits.”

The American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommends that teenagers 13 to 18 years of age should sleep 8 to 10 hours on a regular basis. The AASM also encourages adolescents to disconnect from all electronic devices at least 30 minutes to an hour before bedtime.

Source: American Academy of Sleep Medicine