Tag: 24/10/21

Up to Five Times Higher Costs for Those with Rare Diseases

Credit: Thirdman on Pexels

By studying medical and insurance records indicates health care costs for people with a rare disease, researchers have found that these have been underestimated and are three to five times greater than the costs for people without a rare disease.

The findings, appearing in the Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases, provides new evidence of the impact rare diseases could have on public health, suggesting that medical costs for individuals with rare diseases are on par with those for cancer and heart failure.  

“There needs to be greater public awareness of the large and growing medical footprint of rare diseases in society,” said senior author Anne Pariser, MD, director of the NCATS Office of Rare Diseases Research. “Only about 10% of rare diseases have an FDA-approved therapy for their treatment. The findings underscore an urgent need for more research, and earlier and more accurate diagnoses of and interventions for these disorders.”

Most of the 7000 to 10 000 known rare diseases disproportionately affect children, adolescents and young adults. Individually, most rare diseases might affect only a few hundred to a few thousand people around the world. Rare diseases however are collectively common, affecting an estimated 4% of the world’s population. Many of these diseases have a genetic cause, are serious or life-threatening and are hard to diagnose and treat.

The pilot study used International Classification of Diseases (ICD) codes, which designate a disease diagnosis and other methods, to determine those individuals with rare diseases and their direct medical costs for 14 rare diseases in four health care systems compared to non-rare disease patients of a similar age.

The 14 rare diseases represented a diverse set of disorders differing in prevalence, organ systems affected, age of onset, clinical course, and availability of an approved treatment or specific ICD code. These rare diseases include sickle cell disease, muscular dystrophy and eosinophilic esophagitis.

The analysis showed wide variations of rare diseases prevalence in the different health care systems, possibly due in part to geographic differences, as well as the use of public versus private insurance, which may include different patient group representation. Some genetic diseases can also have a higher prevalence in certain regions, due to demographic make-up.

With the Eversana health care system database, the cost per patient per year (PPPY) for those with a rare disease, ranged from $8 812 to $140 044 for rare diseases patients compared to $5862 for those without a rare disease. The NCATS data indicated PPPY costs ranging from $4859 to $18 994 for rare diseases patients versus $2211 for those without a rare disease.

Using patient medical records, the researchers also traced the diagnostic journeys of four people with a rare disease, including two individuals who had a form of Batten disease, an inherited neurological disorder, and two others with cystic fibrosis. These journeys provided detailed descriptions of direct medical costs, such as for hospitalisations and procedures for these diseases, and provided insights into patient clinical management before and after disease diagnosis.

Analysis of medical records also revealed that rare diseases patients often shared commanilities in symptoms (eg, seizures, infections, and developmental delay) and characteristics, which could aid in earlier diagnosis and treatmen. As many receive a rare disease diagnosis at a young age and because most rare diseases are serious conditions, rare disease patients are likely to require hospital time and incur greater medical expenses over a lifetime.

Such commonalities among rare disease patients could point to the potential use of machine learning techniques on health care system databases to improve diagnoses, said study co-author Joni L. Rutter, PhD, NCATS Acting Director.

The researchers would also like to determine whether these methodologies could be scaled to thousands of other known rare diseases.

“Ultimately, to improve the lives of people with rare diseases,” said Dr Rutter, “we need to find innovative ways, including new technologies, to help shorten the lengthy diagnostic odysseys so many patients and families experience and make more treatments available faster.”

Source: National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences

A New Clue to Disarming C. Difficile’s Toxic Weaponry

C difficile. Source: CDC

Therapeutic interventions for Clostridioides difficile infection (CDI) could make use of a glucosyltransferase domain (GTD) as an ideal molecular target, potentially yielding new, effective treatments for this deadly disease.

The study, published in Science Advancesprovided new insights into TcdB, the toxic molecular weaponry of C. difficile and its hypervirulent strains, creating an opportunity to disarm it.

CDI is the leading cause of antibiotic-associated diarrhoea and gastroenteritis-associated deaths worldwide, accounting for 500 000 cases and 29 000 deaths in the US every year and is classified by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention as one of the top health threats. The emergence and spread of hypervirulent C. difficile strains is of global concern, resembling as it does the occurrence of new virus variants in current COVID pandemic. TcdB is one of two homologous C. difficile exotoxins, and TcdB alone is capable of causing the full spectrum of CDI diseases.

“We focused on the structure and function of TcdB’s crucial GTD, which is the toxin’s ‘warhead.’ The GTD is delivered by the toxin inside the host cells and causes most of the cytosolic damage to patients,” said corresponding author Rongsheng Jin, PhD, professor in the Department of Physiology & Biophysics at the UCI School of Medicine. “We discovered molecular mechanisms by which the GTD specifically recognises and blocks the physiological functions of the human GTPases Rho and R-Ras enzyme families that are crucial signaling molecules.”

The team also showed that the classic form of TcdB and the hypervirulent TcdB recognise their human targets in different ways, leading to distinct structural changes to the host cells caused by bacterial invasion.

“Once the GTD of TcdB is inside the cells, it is shielded by our cells and becomes inaccessible to passive immunotherapy. But our studies suggest that small molecule inhibitors could be developed to disarm the GTD, which will directly eliminate the root cause of disease symptoms and cellular damage,” Prof Jin explained. “This new strategy can potentially be integrated with and complement other CDI treatment regiments.”

Source: UCI School of Medicine