A new study published in Nature Biotechnology identifies risks in the use of CRISPR gene editing, which is employed in a number of therapies. Looking at its use in T cells, the researchers detected a loss of genetic material in a significant percentage – up to 10% of the treated cells. They explain that such loss can lead to destabilisation of the genome, which might cause cancer.
The study was led by Drs Adi Barzel, Dr Asaf Madi and Dr Uri Ben-David at Tel Aviv University.
Developed about a decade ago, CRISPR cleaves DNA sequences at certain locations in order to delete unwanted segments, or alternately repair or insert beneficial segments. It has already proved impressively effective in treating a range of diseases – cancer, liver diseases, genetic syndromes, and more. In 2020 at the University of Pennsylvania, the first approved clinical trial ever to use CRISPR took T cells from a donor, and expressed an engineered receptor targeting cancer cells, while using CRISPR to destroy genes coding for the original receptor – which otherwise might have caused the T cells to attack cells in the recipient’s body.
In the present study, the researchers sought to examine whether the potential benefits of CRISPR therapeutics might be offset by risks resulting from the cleavage itself, assuming that broken DNA is not always able to recover.
Dr Ben-David and his research associate Eli Reuveni explained: “The genome in our cells often breaks due to natural causes, but usually it is able to repair itself, with no harm done. Still, sometimes a certain chromosome is unable to bounce back, and large sections, or even the entire chromosome, are lost. Such chromosomal disruptions can destabilise the genome, and we often see this in cancer cells. Thus, CRISPR therapeutics, in which DNA is cleaved intentionally as a means for treating cancer, might, in extreme scenarios, actually promote malignancies.”
To examine the extent of potential damage, the researchers repeated the 2020 Pennsylvania experiment, cleaving the T cells’ genome in exactly the same locations – chromosomes 2, 7, and 14. Using single-cell RNA sequencing, they analysed each cell separately and measured the expression levels of each chromosome in every cell.
They detected a significant loss of genetic material in some of the cells. For example, when chromosome 14 had been cleaved, about 5% of the cells showed little or no expression of this chromosome. When all chromosomes were cleaved simultaneously, the damage increased, with 9%, 10%, and 3% of the cells unable to repair the break in chromosomes 14, 7, and 2 respectively. The three chromosomes did differ, however, in the extent of the damage they sustained.
Dr Madi and his student Ella Goldschmidt explained: “Single-cell RNA sequencing and computational analyses enabled us to obtain very precise results. We found that the cause for the difference in damage was the exact place of the cleaving on each of the three chromosomes. Altogether, our findings indicate that over 9% of the T-cells genetically edited with the CRISPR technique had lost a significant amount of genetic material. Such loss can lead to destabilisation of the genome, which might promote cancer.”
Based on their findings, the researchers caution that extra care should be taken when using CRISPR therapeutics. They also propose alternative, less risky, methods, for specific medical procedures, and recommend further research into two kinds of potential solutions: reducing the production of damaged cells or identifying damaged cells and removing them before the material is administered to the patient.
Dr Barzel and his PhD student Alessio Nahmad conclude: “Our intention in this study was to shed light on potential risks in the use of CRISPR therapeutics,” adding that as scientists, they “examine all aspects of an issue, both positive and negative, and look for answers.”
Source: EurekAlert!
