UK Children’s Gender Identity Clinic to Close after Controversies

Photo by Sharon McCutcheon on Unsplash

Following a highly critical independent report and accusations of inadequate and unsafe care, the UK will shut down the Tavistock gender identity clinic for children – the only one in the country. It will be replaced by a number of smaller facilities with closer links with mental health care.

The Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust clinic, named the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS), had faced complaints of both long waiting lists for a burgeoning number of referrals, as well as rushing to assign puberty-blocking drugs and cross-sex hormones to children experiencing gender dysphoria.

Concerns had been voiced as early as 2005, when a nurse working at the clinic said that patients were being assessed too quickly and giving in to pressure from interest groups. Nevertheless, demand for its services skyrocketed in later years, from less than 100 per year in 2010 to nearly 2500 by 2018. In 2018, concerns were raised anew, with staff going on to make serious public accusations.

In July 2019, Dr Kirsy Entwhisle, a psychologist at GIDS Leeds hub, said that staff misled patients and made decisions about young people’s “bodies and lives” without “robust evidence”. Some of the children had suffered “very traumatic early experiences” which had not been addressed by the staff. The trust’s safeguarding lead, Sonia Appleby, won a claim from an employment tribunal after trust managers tried to stop her from carrying out her role when staff raised concerns.

One of the loudest critics of Tavistock Centre is Keira Bell, who at 16 was assigned puberty blockers, then cross-sex hormones at 17, and had a double mastectomy at 20 before later de-transitioning.

The former patient, who said she was suffering from anxiety and depression at the time she received treatment, said medics should have considered her mental health issues, “not just reaffirm my naïve hope that everything could be solved with hormones and surgery”.

Along with the unnamed parent of an autistic girl at the clinic, she won a ruling against the NHS assigning cross-sex hormones to children under 16 – but was overturned on appeal.

Helen, a parent of a patient at the clinic, welcomed its closure, but expressed concern for the future of her son’s treatments, according to LGBT site Pink News. While she said her son was treated quickly and received puberty blocking drugs, “From that point on, it felt like it was a little bit like they were winging it,” she said.

During therapy sessions at Tavistock, she said her son was asked a lot of questions and treated “almost like a little bit of an academic curiosity”. She criticised the fact that the same staff evaluated children for medical interventions and also offered therapy session, creating “a fear that they would stop access to medical support”. In contrast to the legal claims of Keira Bell’s and the unnamed patient, she said that GIDS refused to even discuss cross-sex hormones.

Dr David Bell (no relation to Keira Bell) welcomed the closure of Tavistock, telling the BBC: “Some children have got the double problem of living with the wrong treatment, and the original problems weren’t addressed – with complex problems like trauma, depression, large instances of autism.”