A new study appearing in The Lancet Oncology suggests that a targeted radiation therapy is as effective as standard care for patients with lung cancer brain metastasis.
The findings suggests that patients could benefit from this targeted approach as it is known to have have fewer negative cognitive consequences.
In non-small-cell (NSLC) lung cancer, about 57% of patients present with metastatic disease, and 20% present with brain metastases. Brain metastasis is currently treated with whole brain radiation therapy, which targets the entire brain. While this approach treats even microscopic tumours, it results in memory problems and decreases cognitive function. The alternative, stereotactic radiosurgery, spares healthy brain tissue by precisely targeting the tumour, has been shown to have less severe cognitive consequences but has not yet been studied in patients with small cell lung cancer that has metastasised to the brain.
“For many years, it made sense to treat these patients with whole brain radiation because their survival was quite poor,” said Karolina Gaebe, a research student in Dr Sunit Das’s lab, who led the study.
“For them, long-term consequences of the treatment were not as crucial as reducing the impact of disease in the short-term. But now, as treatments for their lung cancer have improved, these patients are surviving much longer.”
The researchers set out to learn more after noticing patients with longer survival times were also living with severe cognitive impairments due to the treatments for their brain metastases. They wanted to understand whether a more targeted brain radiation regimen might be as beneficial for these patients, as has been demonstrated for most other cancer types.
As a first step, they undertook this meta-analysis, reviewing current literature to examine survival and brain outcomes following stereotactic radiosurgery for patients with small cell lung cancer that had spread to the brain. The team analysed data from 31 studies and included 18 130 patients, the largest cohort of small cell lung cancer patients with brain metastases to be studied so far.
The next steps are to conduct a large clinical trial to investigate cognitive outcome differences between stereotactic radiosurgery and whole brain radiation therapy for such patients.
“Because this is a meta-analysis, we can’t use this as absolute evidence that all patients should be treated in this way,” Dr Das said. “But essentially, this means that we need to challenge our standing worldwide paradigms for treating patients with this disease and revisit the idea that these patients should receive whole brain radiation therapy.”
Source: EurekAlert!