There is an urgent need for more standardised and detailed reporting of research on mammalian cells, and for greater control over and measurement of the environmental conditions of cell cultures, according to a recent study. This will improve the precision of human physiology models and contribute to the reproducibility of research.
Researchers analysed 810 randomly selected papers on mammalian cell lines. Fewer than 700 of those, involving 1749 individual cell culture experiments, included relevant data on the environmental conditions of the media in which the cells were cultured. The analysis suggests that the relevance and reproducibility of this type of research needs significant improvement.
“Mammalian cell cultures are fundamental to manufacturing viral vaccines and other biotechnologies,” explained marine scientist, Shannon Klein. “They are used to study basic cell biology, replicate disease mechanisms and investigate the toxicity of novel drug compounds before they are tested on animals and humans.”
Though cells are cultured in controlled incubators in line with standard protocols, cells grow and ‘breathe’ over time and exchange gases with their surrounding environment. This impacts their immediate environment, and even these small changes can affect parameters like culture acidity and dissolved oxygen and carbon dioxide. These changes in turn can affect cell function, causing different conditions to that found in a living human body.
The researchers found that around half of the papers analysed failed to report the temperature and carbon dioxide settings of their cell cultures. Less than 10 percent reported the atmospheric oxygen levels in the incubator and less than 0.01 percent reported the medium’s acidity. No papers reported the dissolved oxygen or carbon dioxide in their media.
“We were very surprised that researchers largely overlooked the maintenance of environmental factors, like culture acidity, at levels relevant to the physiological body over the full course of the cell cultures, despite it being well known that this is important for cell function,” said Ph.D. student Samhan Alsolami.
The team, led by KAUST’s marine ecologist Carlos Duarte and stem cell biologist Mo Li in collaboration with developmental biologist Juan Carlos Izpisua Belmonte from the Salk Institute, who is currently a visiting professor at KAUST, recommends that biomedical scientists develop standard reporting and control and measuring procedures, in addition to employing specialised instruments for controlling the culture environments of different cell types. Additionally, scientific journals should establish reporting standards and require adequate monitoring and control of culture medium acidity and dissolved oxygen and carbon dioxide.
“Better reporting, measurement and control of the environmental conditions of cell cultures should improve how well scientists can repeat and reproduce experimental results,” said Alsolami. “More careful attention could drive new discoveries and increase the relevance of preclinical research to the human body.”
The study is published in Nature Biomedical Engineering.
Source: Medical Xpress
