‘Re-Emphasise Ethical Foundation of Medicine’, ACP Urges

As healthcare services struggling under COVID are bought out by private equity, the American College of Physicians says that it is important to prioritise duty to the patients.

“Today, changing practice dynamics place greater focus on the business aspects of medicine,” the authors wrote in a position paper in the Annals of Internal Medicine. “Although employment or consolidation within larger organisations may not be problematic per se, physicians, regardless of practice setting, should challenge business concerns that are placed above the best interests of patients.”

Practices are often bought out by private equity firms that invest in them and introduce cost-cutting measures to increase market share, and then sell them on to make a profit. This results in pressures to generate financial returns at the ultimate expense of patient care.

“This desire to sell the practice soon after acquisition can create the incentive to sell off parts of the practice or undertake drastic short-term cost-cutting measures, including staff layoffs, to make a potential sale more attractive,” the authors wrote. “Insurance companies may further narrow their networks or restrict patient access to only their employed physicians.”

One example the authors cited was that of Hahnemann University Hospital in Philadelphia, which was shuttered just a year after being bought out by a for-profit corporation. This left patients without access to medical care, and some 570 medical residents and fellows were left with an uncertain future.

The authors also cautioned that private equity firms could also limit Medicaid and Medicare patients due to more complex needs and lower reimbursement. These are government medical schemes that cover lower-income individuals. Medicaid alone covers 1 in 5 Americans.
Value-based payment, the authors noted, is supposed to promote high-quality care, but there are many concerns such as influencing patient choice and creating affordability barriers to treatment. Extrinsic, financial incentives may compete with the intrinsic desire to help patients. They also noted that referral-based payment is subject to similar ethical concerns. Meanwhile, time spent with patients needs to be valued, they wrote, as this is needed to ensure effective communication, examination and to express compassion.

“The challenges to care and medical practice during and after the COVID-19 pandemic underscore the need to reemphasise the ethical foundation of medicine,” the authors wrote. “Looking anew at the environment in which care is delivered, physicians should lead in ensuring that business relationships explicitly recognise and support the fundamental and timeless commitments of physicians and medicine to patients.”

Source: MedPage Today

Journal information: DeCamp M, et al “Ethical and Professionalism Implications of Physician Employment and Health Care Business Practices: A Policy Paper From the American College of Physicians” Ann Intern Med 2021; DOI: 10.7326/M20-7093.