As mass COVID vaccination programmes get underway around the world, an Op-Ed in MedPage Today debates whether people who have recovered from COVID should receive a vaccination.
Even given that there are over 200 vaccines in development, with a typical 7% success rate for vaccines, the 80-95% efficacy reported for the various vaccines being administered and the numbers of successful vaccines is a great outcome. Despite this, considering the great difficulty in producing enough vaccines for the world, should perhaps people who recovered from COVID not receive the vaccine, as they now are protected by a level of immunity?
The perspectives of immunology and bioethics indicate why such a person should also be vaccinated. There would be no difference in vaccinating a person who has had COVID to a person who has recovered then been re-exposed or re-infected. In both cases, a rapid immune response will be mounted in either individual, and either will be asymptomatic or present with mild, manageable symptoms. A re-exposure to the SARS-CoV-2 virus or receiving a vaccine might strengthen such a person’s immunity to future COVID infections.The immune system maintains an immunological library in our lymphatic system which stores memory lymphocytes (B cells) that respond to any past infection encountered by an individual. On a second or third exposure to a particular pathogen, these B cells are mobilised and rapidly prevent re-infection. Vaccines are designed to mimic a viral exposure without eliciting a dangerous viral infection. B cells don’t cause illness, only prompting the immune system, mitigating the infection.
Furthermore, vaccinations confer additional protections beyond just that of the disease which they are meant to protect against. There are abundant data that shows that vaccinations against measles, influenza, or TB generate lymphocytes that even help protect vaccinated individuals against COVID. In one theory on why young children do not present with severe COVID, standard childhood vaccinations are believed to boost their overall level of immunity.
With so many factors complicating vaccine administration, it is best not to add yet another wrinkle, and there is also no information to suggest that vaccinating someone who has recovered from a virus will cause harmful effects. On the contrary, re-exposure to a virus or a subsequent vaccination against that virus could generate superior lymphocytes to combat further infection.
Source:MedPage Today
